---
title: "Catherine Waller's Story: What the Supreme Court Case Means for Property Finance - Independent Legal Advice | ILA | UK's Leading ILA Provider"
description: "Catherine Waller's Supreme Court case changed when lenders must act on the risk of undue influence. What happened, what the law now requires, and what to do differently."
url: "https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/podcasts/catherine-waller-case"
date: "2026-11-19T02:26:41+00:00"
language: "en-GB"
---

#  Catherine Waller's Story: What the Supreme Court Case Means for Property Finance

- [ ](https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ila.co.uk%2Fnews-awards%2Fpodcasts%2Fcatherine-waller-case "Facebook")
- [ ](https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ila.co.uk%2Fnews-awards%2Fpodcasts%2Fcatherine-waller-case&title=Catherine+Waller%27s+Story%3A+What+the+Supreme+Court+Case+Means+for+Property+Finance "LinkedIn")
- [ ](https://twitter.com/share?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ila.co.uk%2Fnews-awards%2Fpodcasts%2Fcatherine-waller-case&text=Catherine+Waller%27s+Story%3A+What+the+Supreme+Court+Case+Means+for+Property+Finance "X (formerly Twitter)")

### At a Glance

Catherine Waller is the appellant in Waller-Edwards v One Savings Bank Plc \[2025\] UKSC 22, the Supreme Court case that has clarified when lenders are put on inquiry as to undue influence. She recently joined Anastasia Ttofis on ILA On Air to share her story publicly for the first time. This is a blend of the legal facts, her personal account, and what needs to change across the property and finance industry as a result.

### How It Started

In late 2011, Catherine Waller was in one of the hardest periods of her life. Her mother had recently died. She was raising two teenagers alone. Her home had suffered a severe sewage flood she was still fighting to resolve. Despite all of this, she was financially secure. She owned her home outright, worth around £600,000, with £150,000 in savings and a modest pension.

It was during this period that she met Nicholas Bishop, a local builder and property developer.

"He seemed a really nice guy," she told us. "Genuine, honest, kind. He was very, very helpful. What I didn't know was he was lying to me from the day he met me."

Bishop was, at the time, facing his own financial pressure, including a looming dispute over a development project and an unresolved divorce. Within a year, he had persuaded Catherine to exchange her mortgage-free home and her savings for a stake in a property he was building nearby, known as Spectrum.

### What Actually Happened, Legally

The property already carried an existing £78,000 charge, owed by Bishop to a third party. Catherine was given a second charge over Spectrum to secure her investment. The property was held in joint names, 1% to Bishop and 99% to Catherine.

"I felt there's some protection," she said. "And when it turns out at the court, and with the bank, that doesn't mean anything, because as soon as somebody has 1% and you have 99% it becomes a joint equity in law. And I didn't understand that at the time. Obviously, who would?"

In 2013, Bishop arranged to remortgage Spectrum with One Savings Bank for £384,000. The same solicitor acted for Bishop, for the bank, and for Catherine.

The bank understood that £233,000 of the loan would clear the existing charge on the property, and £100,000 would go towards a home the couple would share. It also required £25,000 to clear Bishop's car finance and £14,500 to clear his personal credit card, a combined £39,500 that would benefit Bishop alone.

What the bank did not know was that £142,000 of the money advanced was, in fact, used to make a divorce settlement payment to Bishop's ex-wife. The shared home was never bought.

"Because I never saw the broker. The broker never saw me," Catherine said. Of the bank, she added: "The lender knew. And the lender made it a condition of the mortgage... And they were his debts. They weren't mine."

### When the Relationship Changed

Catherine dates the change to much earlier, once the 2012 transfers were complete. Bishop moved out in 2014, leaving her in a heavily mortgaged property on a limited income.

"As soon as he got control of all my assets, that's things changed," she told us. "I started to become very uneasy, scared. He was telling lies. But at the time I still thought this is going to be where we're going with our life, and he's stressed at work. As a woman, or as perhaps anyone, you make excuses for people."

She described being taken to solicitors' offices without understanding what she was signing. In her words: "My abuser was in the room with me."

"I was wheeled in as a cash cow. I was wheeled in for a signature and that was it," she said. "I was basically told to say nothing before we went in. I didn't know what to say anyway. I didn't understand it."

### The Fight Through the Courts

Arrears built up, and in 2021, One Savings Bank began possession proceedings. Catherine argued she had entered the remortgage under undue influence.

The trial judge agreed undue influence had occurred, but ruled the bank had no obligation to act, because the transaction was structured as joint borrowing rather than a straightforward guarantee of someone else's debt. The High Court and Court of Appeal both upheld this, applying what became known as the "fact and degree" test.

Catherine took the case to the Supreme Court.

On 4 June 2025, the Court unanimously allowed her appeal. Delivering the leading judgment, Lady Simler rejected the lower courts' approach in favour of what has become known as the "bright line" test: a lender is put on inquiry in any non-commercial hybrid transaction where, on the face of it, a more than trivial element of the loan is used to discharge one borrower's debts and so might not be to the other's financial advantage. Once put on inquiry, the lender must follow the Etridge protocol: communicating directly with the borrower, requiring written confirmation from a solicitor acting for her that the nature and practical implications of the transaction have been fully explained, and asking her to nominate that solicitor. She notably added that this is "not a radical departure from the present position".

The £39,500 earmarked for Bishop's debts was held to be more than de minimis. As Lady Simler put it, "no-one could regard a surety component of £39,500 as de minimis or trivial". The appeal was allowed. The Court left the consequences to the parties, noting that in the absence of agreement it may be necessary for the case to be remitted to the county court on the question of remedy.

### What This Means Beyond the Judgment

Catherine is nearly 66. She told us that if she had lost her case, she believes she would have been sleeping in her car.

"I would have lost everything that I'd worked for, from 14, when I started in a cafe, and worked and saved. And that's how I've got through life. And I would have lost everything. And yes, because I met that abuser in that cafe, but also because I was failed at each stage by the solicitors, the broker, the bank."

She took her case through four courts to get here. And she told us that, even now, she remains named on the mortgage with her former partner. "I'm still on the mortgage with my abuser," she said. The question of remedy has yet to be resolved.

"That's why I'm here," she told Anastasia. "That's why I contacted you. I want change."

### What the Industry Needs to Do Differently

The Etridge protections have existed since

2001\. What was genuinely unclear, until this ruling, was when they were triggered in a loan that was part joint borrowing and part one partner's own debt. That uncertainty is why the case had to reach the Supreme Court, and it is now settled. The practical question for the industry is what to do with that certainty.

If you're a lender: any non-commercial joint loan where more than a trivial part of the funds is used to clear one borrower's own debts now automatically puts you on inquiry.

The question is no longer whether the transaction looks like joint borrowing overall. This is no longer a judgement call.

If you're a broker: meet your client directly. Verifying an identity document for someone you have never spoken to is not verification. It is a signature on a form.

If you're a solicitor or conveyancer: the protocol requires the borrower to have the nature and practical implications of the transaction fully explained to her, and for the lender to receive written confirmation from a solicitor acting for her that this has been done. She should be asked to nominate that solicitor, and asked whether she would prefer someone other than the solicitor already acting. In practice that means explaining in plain English, and pausing if she cannot say what the loan is for. The confirmation a lender relies on is only as good as the conversation behind it.

If you're anyone in the transaction chain: ask the question that feels awkward. What are your circumstances? Do you understand what you're signing? As Catherine put it:

"Nobody asked that. Nobody asked if I could support the mortgage or do anything like that."

### Listen to Catherine's Full Story

This blog cannot capture everything Catherine shared. Her full conversation with Anastasia is available now on ILA On Air, and we would encourage anyone working in property, finance or law to listen to it in full.

[Full Episode Here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dp378iqPgWw)

**[ANASTASIA TTOFIS](https://www.ila.co.uk/about-us/anastasia)**

CO-FOUNDER & CEO

[020 4571 9207](tel:020%204571%209207)

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

[LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/anastasia-ila/)

 ![Anastasia Ttofis](//iladvice.b-cdn.net/images/2025/06/02/anastasia-white-bg.webp)

### Recent Articles

### [Catherine Waller's Story: What the Supreme Court Case Means for Property Finance](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/podcasts/catherine-waller-case)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/podcasts/catherine-waller-case)

### [Economic Abuse in Property Finance – Key Takeaways from Waller-Edwards v One Savings Bank](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/waller-edwards-one-savings-bank-case-explained)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/waller-edwards-one-savings-bank-case-explained)

[![Why independent legal advice is worth the cost, person signing legal documents.](//iladvice.b-cdn.net/images/hands-paper-and-pen-for-signature-with-business-p-2026-01-09-09-51-05-utc.jpg)](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/skipping-independent-legal-advice-risks)### [Why Independent Legal Advice Often Costs Less Than the Risk of Skipping It](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/skipping-independent-legal-advice-risks)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/skipping-independent-legal-advice-risks)

[![The Best Business Law in Poole, UK](//iladvice.b-cdn.net/images/2026/11/03/2026-winner1_thumbnail.jpg)](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/the-best-business-law-in-poole-uk)### [The Best Business Law in Poole, UK](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/the-best-business-law-in-poole-uk)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/the-best-business-law-in-poole-uk)

[![Top Ten Legal Influencers 2026](//iladvice.b-cdn.net/images/2026/11/03/top-ten-legal-influencers_thumbnail.jpg)](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/top-ten-legal-influencers-2026)### [Top Ten Legal Influencers 2026](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/top-ten-legal-influencers-2026)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/press/top-ten-legal-influencers-2026)

[![Property in Practice Magazine September 2026, property professional at work.](//iladvice.b-cdn.net/images/confident-architect-with-plans-on-construction-site.jpg)](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/property-in-practice-magazine-september-2026)### [Property in Practice Magazine September 2026 - Key Property Law Updates](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/property-in-practice-magazine-september-2026)

[➜](https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/education/property-in-practice-magazine-september-2026)

## Schema

```json
{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "BreadcrumbList", "itemListElement": [ { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 1, "name": "Home", "item": "https://www.ila.co.uk" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 2, "name": "Education & Media", "item": "https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 3, "name": "Podcasts", "item": "https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/podcasts" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 4, "name": "Catherine Waller's Story: What the Supreme Court Case Means for Property Finance", "item": "https://www.ila.co.uk/news-awards/podcasts/catherine-waller-case.md" } ] }
```
